At last. Here are complete Efficiency Rankings measuring the efficiency with which universities turn inputs into citations. I am using the method of Professor Dirk van Damme which is to divide the scores for Citations: Research Influence in The THE World University Rankings by the scores for Research: Volume, Income and Reputation. Here is the method as cited in a previous post:
"The input indicator takes scaled and normalised measures of research income and volume into account, and also considers reputation, while the output indicator looks at citations to institutional papers in Thomson Reuters’ Web of Science database, normalised for subject differences.
Professor van Damme said that the results - which show that university systems outside the Anglo-American elite are able to realise and increase outputs with much lower levels of input - did not surprise him.
“For example, Switzerland really invests in the right types of research. It has a few universities in which it concentrates resources, and they do very well,” he said.
Previous studies have found the UK to have the most efficient research system on measures of citation per researcher and per unit of spending.
But Professor van Damme explained that under his approach, productivity - output per staff member - was included as an input.
“With efficiency I mean the total research capacity of an institution, including its productivity, divided by its impact. The UK is not doing badly at all, but other countries are doing better, such as Ireland, which has a very low research score but a good citations score,” he said.
Given the severity of the country’s economic crisis, Ireland’s success was particularly impressive, he said.
“I think it is really conscious of the effort it has to make to maintain its position and is doing so.”
Low efficiency scores for China and South Korea reflected the countries’ problems in translating their huge investment into outputs, he added."
1. Tokyo Metroplitan
2. Moscow Engineering Physics Institute
3. Florida Institute of Technology
4. Southern Methodist
5. Hertfordshire
6. Portsmouth
7= King Mongkut's University of Technology
7= Vigo
9. Creighton
10. Fribourg
11. King Abdulaziz
12. University of the Andes
13. Trieste
14. Renmin
15. Medical University of Vienna
16. Polytech University Valencia
17= Beyreuth
18= Montana
19. Mainz
20. Ferrara
21. Drexel
22. Valencia
23. Linz
24. Crete
25. Colorado School of Mines
26. Technical University of Dresden
27. Innsbruck
28. Nurnberg
29= Dauphine
29= Wake Forest
29= Maryland Baltimore County
32. St George's London
33. William and Mary College
34. Hong Kong Baptist
35. Basel
36. Texas San Antonio
37. Duisberg
38. Lyon 1
39. Wurzburg
40. Charles Darwin
41. Wayne State
42. Northeastern
43. Bicocca
44. Royal Holloway
45. Koc
46. Georgia University of Health Science
47. Modena
48. Dundee
49. Southern Denmark
50= IIT Roorkhee
50= Pompeu Fabra
52. Graz
53= Oregon
53= Diderot
55. Bielfeld
56. Munster
57. Waikato
58= Grenoble
59= East Anglia
60= Bonn
61= Pavia
62. ENS Lyon
63. Eastern Finland
64. Padua
65. Brandeis
66. Aberystwyth
67. Tulane
68. Tubingen
69= Warsaw
70= Sun Yat Sen
71= Keele
72. Tromso
73. Brunel
74. Liege
75. Queen Mary
76= Vermont
77= Trento
78. Turin
79. Jyvaskyla
80. Carleton
81. Kansas
82. California Riverside
83. SUNY Stony Brook
84= George Washington
85= Pisa
86. Tasmania
87. George Mason
88. Boston College
89= Oregon State
90= Texas Dallas
91. Trinity College Dublin
92= University Science and Technology China
92= Murdoch
92= Cinncinati
92= Galway
92= Yeshiva
97= Tufts
97= Minho
99. Miami
100. Lehigh
101. Technical University Denmark
102= Rice
102= Iceland
104. California Santa Cruz
104= Milan
106. Monpellier 2
107. Frankfurt
108= Bergen
109= Strasbourg
110. Victoria
111. Rochester
112. Cork
113. Dartmouth
114. Oklahoma
115. Birkbeck
116. Porto
117. Canterbury
118= Newcastle UK
118= Notre Dame
118= University College Dublin
121. Binghamton
122. Aveiro
123= Kiel
123= Sussex
125. Temple
126. Aachen
127= Fribourg
127= Queens Belfast
127= Colorado Boulder
130. Iowa State
131. Tokyo Medical Dental
132= Autonomous Madrid
132= Swedish Agriculture
132= Tempere
135= Deakin
135= Barcelona
137= Stockholm
137= Stirling
139. Laval
140. Durham
141. Bangor
142= Aberdeen
142= Vanderbilt
144. Istanbul Technical
145. Nanjing
146= Exeter
146= Emory
146= Leicester
149. Southamton
150. Paris Mines
151. Vrije Universiteit Brussel
152. Polytechnic Milan
153. Kwazulu-Natal
154= Linkoping
154= Bilkent
154= Herriot-Watt
154= Bologna
158= Wyoming
158= Utah
158= Massey
161= Glasgow
161= Bern
163. ENS Paris
164. Zurich
165= Case Western Reserve
166= California Irvine
167= Tartu
168= Wellington
169= Salento
170. South Carolina
171. York UK
172. Aalto
173= Curie
173= Macquarie
173= Boston
176= Delaware
177= Copenhagen
178= Hannover
179. Norway University of Science and Technology
180. Antwerp
181= Dalhousie
181= Renselaer Polytechnic Institute
183= Konstanz
184= Paris Sud
185. Technical University Munich
186. Lancaster
187. Waseda
188. Otago
189. Arizona State
190= SUNY Albany
190= Gottingen
190= Autonomous Barcelona
193= Cape Town
194= St Andrews
195= Colorado State
195= Bath
195= Wollongong
198= Tsukuba
198= Simon Fraser
198= Liverpool
198= Umea
202= Geneva
202= Newcastle Australia
204= Universite Libre Bruxelles
204= Virginia
206= Lausanne
206= Louvain
208= Connecticut
208= Georgetown
208= York Canada
211. EPF Lausanne
212= North Carolina State
212= Bristol
212= Aalborg
212= Free University Amsterdam
216= Indiana
216= Kentucky
218. Maryland College Park
219. Karlsruhe Institute technology
220= University Technology Sydney
220= Iowa
222. Charles
223. Flinders
224. Cardiff
225= Auckland
225= Oslo
227. Pittsburgh
228= Heidelberg
228= Guelph
228= Washington State
228= Sheffield
232= Chinese University Hong Kong
232= Strathclyde
234= Ottawa
234= Gotherberg
234= Washington St Louis
237. Medical South Carolina
238= McMaster
238= Brown
238= National Sun Yat Sen
238= Reading
242. Ecole Polytechnique
243. Helsinki
244= Quebec
244= National Central Taiwan
246. Bogazici
247= Southern California
247= Arizona
249. Keio
250= Houston
250= Stellenbosch
250= Kings College London
250= Darmstadt
250= Western Australia
255= Pohang
255= IIT Bombay
257= Wageningen
257= Manitoba
259= South Australia
259= Nagoya
261= Leeds
261= UC Santa Barbara
261= Nijmegen
261= Jagiellon
265= New York University
265= Calgary
265= Ohio State
268. Aarhus
269= Witwatersrand
269= North Carolina Chapel Hill
269= Michigan State
269= Fudan
273= Bochum
273= Munich
275= SUNY Buffalo
275= Adelaide
275= Sapienza
278= Utrecht
278= Edinburgh
278= Queensland University of Technology
281= Lund
281= Ghent
283. Erasmus
284= Massachusetts
284= Illinois Chicago
284= Nottingham
287= Eindhoven
287= Amsterdam
289. UC San Diego
290. Birmingham
291= Western Ontario
291= Twente
293= Washington Seattle
293= Duke
295= Penn State
295= NUI Maynooth
297= Maastricht
297= Groningen
297= Columbia
297= Leiden
297= Georgia
302. UC Davis
303= Southern Florida
303= Chalmers University of Technology
305= Minnesota
305= Essex
305= Manchester
305= Georgia Institute of Technology
309= Rutgers
309= Texas at Austin
311= Northwestern
311= Warwick
311= Vienna
311= MIT
315. Johns Hopkins
316= Wisconsin Madison
316= Carnegie Mellon
318. Alberta
319. Pennsylvania
320= Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
320= Kyushu
322= Chicago
322= Vienna University of Technology
324= Queensland
324= Montreal
326. British Columbia
327= Yale
327= Imperial College London
327= UCLA
327= Hebrew University of Jerusalem
327= Karolinska
332= Melbourne
332= Humboldt
332= National Tsinghua Taiwan
332= Cambridge
332= Harvard
332= Stanford
338= Monash
338= Princeton
338= Caltech
338= Michigan
338= UC Berkeley
338= Cornell
344= Waterloo
344= KHT Sweden
344= Missouri
347. University College London
348= Oxford
348= Middle East Technical University
350. Yonsei
351= Toronto
351= Illinois Urbana Champagne
351= Peking
351= Leuven
355= Zhejiang
355= Hokkaido
355= Hong Kong Polytechnic University
355= McGill
359= ETH Zurich
359= Tokyo Institute of Technology
361= Berlin
361= Uppsala
363= Korea
363= Sydney
365= Florida
365= New South Wales
367= Australian National
367= Tohoku
367= Purdue
367= Technion
371= Surrey
371= IIT Kharagpur
373= KAIST
373= Texas A and M
375. Virginia Polytechnic Institute
376= Osaka
376= Nanyang Technological University
376= Shanghai Jiao Tong
379. LSE
380. Sungkyunkwan
381. Sharif University of Technology
382. Tokyo
383= National Taiwan University of Science and Technology
383= National Autonomous University of Mexico
385= Kyoto
385= National University of Singapore
387. Loughborough
388. National Cheng Kung
389. Tel Aviv
390= Hong Kong
390= Tsinghua
392. Chinese University of Hong Kong
393. National Taiwan
394. National Chiao Tung
395. Tilburg
396. Delft
397. Seoul National
398. State University Campinas
399. Sao Paulo
400. Moscow State
No comments:
Post a Comment